Golo
trublue in wake county: blog

trublue in wake county's blog


federal court upholds ban of confederate flag clothing in tennessee high school

Published Aug. 21, 2008

Southern Pride or Symbol of hate??? Would they have done the same for a student wearing a Malcolm X t-shirt? or Vice Versa??? 

NASHVILLE, Tenn. —  A federal appeals court panel has ruled in favor of a Tennessee high school that banned students from wearing clothing with the Confederate battle flag after several racial incidents.

Students Derek Barr, Chris White and Roger Craig White claimed in a lawsuit that their free speech rights were violated by the 2005 ban on the Confederate symbol at William BloFeunt High School in Maryville.

School officials said their ban came after racial tension that included a fight, a civil rights complaint and graffiti of a Confederate flag, a racial slur and a noose.

In its opinion filed Wednesday in Cincinnati, the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that school officials had a right to ban the flag because they could "reasonably forecast" that it would disrupt education.



41 Comments


Golo

Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.

You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.



page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

...federal government cannot tell us what to do." South Carolina votes to succeed from the Union....

Succeed? Succeed at what? As in accomplish?

The correct word is: Main Entry: se·cede Pronunciation: \si-ˈsēd\ Function: intransitive verb Inflected Form(s): se·ced·ed; se·ced·ing to withdraw from an organization (as a religious communion or political party or federation)

If you are going to argue your point about why the south did what it what it did, dont validates the others side opionon of you by using the wrong word to make your point

this argument was fought and won in another state, and the kids were allowed to wear them. Just because you don't like something doesn't mean you get to act on it in a violent way. any kid that would react with violence to a symbol shouldn't be in school anyway.

a chorus from Gen Alberts Pikes version of the song "Dixie"

Fear no danger! Shun no labor! Lift up rifle, pike, and saber! To arms! To arms! To arms, in Dixie! Shoulder pressing close to shoulder, Let the odds make each heart bolder! To arms! To arms! To arms, in Dixie!

White skin is a vestige of historic wrongs, and a constant offensive reminder of systemic institutional racism and unearned privilege. Thus, it must be made illegal, and must not be worn or displayed.

Thank you for your cooperation.

"unless they wear uniforms this is a civil rights violation, no profanity on the shirt, then it has to stay."

No, I think the court is dead on with this ruling. The key phrase is "they could 'reasonably forecast' that it would disrupt education". Other examples would be banning articles of clothing like mini-skirts and revealing tops on girls, hats on boys, or gang affiliated attire. All can/are disruptive to the main purpose of school which is education.

"Some have adopted the flag as a symbol of hate, like the Nazis did with the swastika."

I agree and it really t's me off to see some dumb bunny wearing it as a Aryan pride symbol as that is so off base. I have battle flag and the last thing I equate with it is nazis.

I remember when I was a D.I in South Carolina when the flag on the state capital still flew. Strom Thrumond came down the stairs and stated "you mean if we keep it flying, they will boycott the state" Meaning J. Jackson and his cronies "sounds like a win-win situation to me" and he walked back up the steps, to the shock and horror of the five points educated news crew......I fell out of my chair laughing...

American by birth - Southern by the Grace of God!

Since I don't try to tell others how to mind their business, I would surely love it if they would keep their noses out of mine! However in the great state of Georgia, our governor decided the state flag needed changing and we weren't even allowed to vote on it! Don't all of you just love that "one person - one vote" rule?

During my younger hunting days, I wore a cavalry hate with the Confederate flag. When I worked out west for a while, I had the flag on my office wall. No one complained. They knew it symbolized my southern heritage. This was before people were told to be offended by it. Now that I’m back on southern soil, I can’t fly it within causing controversy. Some have adopted the flag as a symbol of hate, like the Nazis die with the swastika. But that shouldn’t be cause to ban those of us that fly it for southern pride, nothing more, nothing less. I still fly the Confederate flag on my boat. I wish I could have it on my office wall.

Sorry for the duplicate paste error.

There were three versions of the Confederate National flag and then there is the battle flag which is the one that is always causing the controversy

There were three versions of the Confederate National flag and then there is the battle flag which is the one that is always causing the controversy.

If this symbol is to be banned in school then all symbols will have to be, otherwise they are opening themselves up for a lawsuit, which they would probably loose.

Southerners will always have an undying loyalty to the South so get used to it. We still revere our flag and heritage

page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Please log in to add comment.

most recent
   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

obama mother in law to move in the white house ?

The family says they expect Michelle Obama's mother, Marian Robinson, to leave her native Chicago...

for spunky

My definition of a true friend.                 ...

some wings for the partay

********* HAPPY FRIDAY EVERYONE *********     See...

a grinch steals donated goods intended to honor a hero's service

photo of Fallen Hero - Army Capt. Matthew Ferrara, 24 - NOT the grinch! Southern California...

my golo friends

You know, I had all but left golo because of all the BS that's been on here for so many months... ...

question for you...

what is your definition of a true friend? I have reasons for asking this... My definition of...

what if you had a chance to live in another time and place?

  The original Star Trek series had an episode where the Enterprise visits a planet...

pregnant woman asks for help, gets ticket

Commentary: Pregnant woman asks for help, gets ticket Story Highlights Story comes from...

fight of the year!!!

Oscar De La Hoya or Manny Pacquiao?  I love me some De La Hoya, but Manny is fast and the best pound for pound.  Who are you going with?

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

profile of motherof3girls

Concerned mother of 3

profile of carolinafan

Let's keep our American values!

profile of no news is good news

I see a lot of personal vendettas, especially towards social technology in WRAL's articles (facebook...

profile of jn1010life

To speak & live the truth even when I don't want to.

profile of christineswisher

I have no personal statement.  I just have opinions about the stories on this website.

profile of apexperson

I live in apex

profile of evil1

Life is like a box of cat trrds.

profile of nthdegree63

I believe that every day is a fresh start and a new oportunity to learn something. So every day I try to learn a new thing, and pass that knowledge along to someone else.

profile of highlight3

A Change has come!

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

wide awake club (10 members)

As a night shift person, I tend to be awake when most of the world is asleep.  I know I am not the...

santas secret (5 members)

This group is going to play santa to a few families  

press releases of interest (9 members)

I get a lot of press releases. I will post some of them here. Join the group if you're interested. Many of them will be set to "members only."

poets corner (8 members)

They say nobody reads poetry any more. Let's prove them wrong! Join the Poets' Corner and post your...

coffee lovers (26 members)

This group is desinged to all the coffee lovers out there in Golo land.. I will try to have...

the readers room (18 members)

A place to discuss what you have been reading. Do you recommend it? Should there be a skull and crossbones...

diabetics...we are too sweet (13 members)

I found out today that I am officially a diabetic.   My A1C was 10.1. A great friend...

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

profile of grumpy-not

Try to find the good in everyone and everything. There is nothing better in life than having...

profile of kcobra

Live life to its fullest. You may not get another chance to be bad. No better friend, No worse...

profile of sessy v--v

American Marines of 7th Regiment catching some sleep in an Amtrak after securing the...

profile of spunky-cancerwarrior

  ----------------------------------------------------------------- For Camphost:...

profile of packy kracka

I think some golo folks have done up and lost their dayum minds while I've been gone....  What's up?!  lol

profile of ms. mocha

G@ME   If my heart is pierced by your words and my frowns...